Sometimes questions tell us more than answers do.
by Matthias Hoefler
“They have taken away the Lord out of the tomb,
. . . ,” Mary Magdalene tells the disciples (John 20:2).
John and Peter run there. They look in. They enter. She’s right: Jesus isn’t there.
John and Peter return home. Mary stays behind weeping. The easy thing would be to go home too. But Mary loved this man Jesus who did so much for her. The pain she feels is all she has left of Jesus, so she sits there in that pain. Sometimes that’s all we have left.
We have felt what Mary felt. We’ve loved people and lost ones who really added to our lives. I think of the ache I felt when my mom died.
Mary’s world is in pieces at her feet, glass shards too small to mend. And she doesn’t know where what’s left of her world has gone. “They have taken away the Lord . . . and we do not know where they have laid Him” (v. 2).
With tracks of her tears on her face, Mary looks up from her hands and into the tomb a second time. Maybe she doesn’t even know why. When she does look in, the Bible doesn’t say she sees the folded grave clothes that John and Peter noted. Instead, she sees two seated angels, wearing white. “Then they said to her, ‘Woman, why are you weeping?’” (v. 13).
Did taking a second look — sitting with her pain and confusion a while, lingering — lead to seeing these angels? Maybe there’s something in the angelic concern for her that nudges Mary toward belief. The angels’ concern reminds Mary of the concern Another had for her, this Man who loved her like no other.
A second look
Thinking of that concern, Mary turns from the angels and “sees” Jesus again. He repeats the angels’ question but adds something, nudging her even closer. “Why are you weeping? Whom are you seeking?” (v. 15).
Mary doesn’t recognize Jesus. A trick of the light? She can’t see through her tears? She thinks He’s the gardener. She still wonders where Jesus has been taken.
“Sir, if You have carried Him away, tell me where You have laid Him, and I will take Him away” (v. 15). She must see Jesus’ body treated as it should be.
Mary gets so much more than she’s hoping for. Did anyone say her name the way He did? When Jesus speaks her name now, Mary knows it is He (vv. 14-16). Excited and filled with joy, she embraces Him (v. 17).
Rewards
If you’re in pain today, be encouraged: Sitting in a painful tension — often all we can manage — is rewarded here. Like Mary, we can reach toward Jesus, trusting He will reveal Himself in His time, as He did to her. This is the same tomb Peter and John just looked into and even walked around in. They saw what they saw.
But with this second look, Mary saw something quite different. She was rewarded with seeing beings beyond this mud-and-grass world that very few people have ever seen. And then she got to welcome Jesus back to the earth with an embrace.
Why was Mary’s experience so different? Was it because Peter and John were men and Mary was a woman? Was her faith stronger? Was it something about her way of relating to Jesus before He was murdered? Maybe something else we would recognize had we spent time with them? Mary was forgiven much. Perhaps her experience was different because she loved much (Luke 7:47) or because He had made her whole (8:2).
However it is, John, Mary, and Peter would each be thrilled to see Jesus that morning, but only Mary did, initially. And she had the privilege of becoming His messenger to the remaining disciples (John 20:18).
God’s questions
Sometimes struggling with a question is revelatory. The Lord often uses questions as tools. He asked Adam, “Where are you?” (Genesis 3:9). The Lord asked Jacob, “What is your name?” (32:27). Job was asked by the Almighty, “Where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth?” (Job 38:4). And Jesus asked many questions, including “Who do you say that I am?” (Matthew 16:15); “Do you want to be made well?” (John 5:6); and “Do you also want to go away?” (6:67).
The questions are about us — often what we want and need. But in trying to answer, somehow, we can be led to the Lord Jesus.
On top of her own questions about her Messiah’s baffling death, Mary received questions from the angels, and more from Jesus. As the queries mounted, what did she hear that morning? Maybe hearing “Whom are you seeking?” echoed in her mind as well as in her overwhelmed, aching heart. Maybe the questions centered Mary on Jesus even more intensely, whose death had all but emptied her. Were the questions necessary to prepare her for the shock of seeing Him again?
Mary stayed by Jesus’ side, even after He was gone, and received a reward beyond all price. Let’s follow her example and stay as near Jesus as we can. For in Christ, all of us have received much more than we could have hoped for, just as Mary did that day.



